"When Sean V. sends me an email, I can ignore it. When he comes to my desk, I pay attention."
Heads nodded around the room. They knew the guy, and had all done the same.
Thursday I met with some co-workers and colleagues about the CFC. The Combined Federal Campaign is the Fed's version of United Way. It is a clearinghouse for money donated by federal employees to national and local charities. Hundreds of charities to choose from, each with their own mission, overhead, and goals.
And every year, we go through the same thing. Skits. Poking fun at the bosses, who are asked to humiliate themselves - pie throwing, dunking booth, silly skits, whatever. But the result has been a decline over time in participation rate.
It used to be the case that employees donated to the church and to whatever the office charity was. And the donations continued throughout the career, adjusting for increases in pay and promotions. If you were in charge of getting donations, you could pretty much count on the combination of peer pressure (everyone is doing their part) and a little bit of amusement to get full compliance.
And then came Dateline.
Now, with 24-hour news channels, we have exposés about everything under the sun. And there is little that we love more than seeing the CEO of a non-profit go down. So hidden cameras and gotcha moments and microphones stuffed into the face of people who are gaming the system... all part and parcel of our modern lives.
And so begins a distrust of charity. The mistrust does not only extend to the one charity who was exposed, but to all. The underlying assumption now is, everybody cheats. Only one got caught.
So the youngest workers tend to have no faith in the system we are in charge of pushing. They are demanding; they want to see real results for what they do. They are ready to volunteer than donate, and they give the stink-eye to large, corporate-style fundraising. Like what we are doing.
Unfortunately, the resulting harm is often greater than the benefit.
I am no homebuilder. My volunteer hours are better spent apprenticing for a job where I show some aptitude - say, cleaning latrines or shoveling horse manure. (Maybe removing bees from columns - but that one comes up very rarely in charity work.)
Heads nodded around the room. They knew the guy, and had all done the same.
Thursday I met with some co-workers and colleagues about the CFC. The Combined Federal Campaign is the Fed's version of United Way. It is a clearinghouse for money donated by federal employees to national and local charities. Hundreds of charities to choose from, each with their own mission, overhead, and goals.
And every year, we go through the same thing. Skits. Poking fun at the bosses, who are asked to humiliate themselves - pie throwing, dunking booth, silly skits, whatever. But the result has been a decline over time in participation rate.
It used to be the case that employees donated to the church and to whatever the office charity was. And the donations continued throughout the career, adjusting for increases in pay and promotions. If you were in charge of getting donations, you could pretty much count on the combination of peer pressure (everyone is doing their part) and a little bit of amusement to get full compliance.
And then came Dateline.
Now, with 24-hour news channels, we have exposés about everything under the sun. And there is little that we love more than seeing the CEO of a non-profit go down. So hidden cameras and gotcha moments and microphones stuffed into the face of people who are gaming the system... all part and parcel of our modern lives.
![]() |
Corporate Stinkeye |
So the youngest workers tend to have no faith in the system we are in charge of pushing. They are demanding; they want to see real results for what they do. They are ready to volunteer than donate, and they give the stink-eye to large, corporate-style fundraising. Like what we are doing.
Unfortunately, the resulting harm is often greater than the benefit.
I am no homebuilder. My volunteer hours are better spent apprenticing for a job where I show some aptitude - say, cleaning latrines or shoveling horse manure. (Maybe removing bees from columns - but that one comes up very rarely in charity work.)